• Cars
    +7K
  • About
  • Blog
EN
Add car
  1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. News
  4. Why automatic braking may miss a pedestrian in reflective clothing: ADAC test
News

Why automatic braking may miss a pedestrian in reflective clothing: ADAC test

Konstantin Lupandin
Konstantin Lupandin
October 29, 20263 min readViews: 441
Add as preferred source
  1. Which cars were tested and how
  2. What happened when the dummies changed clothes
  3. One successful scenario does not make a car infallible
  4. Why a system can make a mistake
  5. Do these results change the value of reflective clothing?
  6. What drivers should check in their own car
  7. What other tests show

Contents

  1. Which cars were tested and how
  2. What happened when the dummies changed clothes
  3. One successful scenario does not make a car infallible
  4. Why a system can make a mistake
  5. Do these results change the value of reflective clothing?
  6. What drivers should check in their own car
  7. What other tests show
Why automatic braking may miss a pedestrian in reflective clothing: ADAC test

Reflective clothing helps drivers spot pedestrians in the dark. But it proved challenging for some automatic emergency braking systems. In a test by German motoring club ADAC, nearly all the cars tested failed to respond in time to a child dummy wearing reflective clothing and a backpack.

The results were published on 27 October 2026. Researchers tested six cars in several scenarios in darkness. The finding applies to the specific test conditions, not every car or encounter with reflective material.

Which cars were tested and how

The study included the Mercedes CLA, Tesla Model Y, BYD Seal, Hyundai Tucson, Dacia Duster and Opel Astra. The cars had to respond to adult and child dummies wearing different clothing.

ADAC first tested the systems at several speeds using dummies without high-visibility clothing. For each car and scenario, the researchers selected the highest speed at which a collision could still be avoided. They then used that speed as the reference for tests with different clothing.

This is not a ranking of the six models: each car had its own reference speed, so ADAC cautions against comparing their results directly. The club did not state the test date in its press release.

What happened when the dummies changed clothes

Scenario in darkness

ADAC result

Adult dummy in an ordinary high-visibility vest

All six cars detected the situation and avoided a collision.

Adult dummy in standardised reflective workwear

Nearly all cars failed to detect the pedestrian or detected it too late to stop.

Child dummy in dark clothing

All cars detected the dummy.

Child dummy in reflective clothing with a backpack

Nearly all systems failed. Only the Mercedes CLA detected the child in the scenario where it emerged from behind a parked car.

The distinction between the first two scenarios matters: the result does not mean a car will necessarily ignore everyone wearing a reflective vest. It depended on the dummy's appearance in the particular test.

One successful scenario does not make a car infallible

The Mercedes CLA detected the child dummy emerging from behind a parked car, showing that a system can handle such a situation. But the study does not prove that the CLA or any other car will stop for a pedestrian at every speed and in every condition.

Why a system can make a mistake

Automatic emergency braking, or AEB, is designed to help when a collision is imminent. It processes sensor data, assesses the situation and, when necessary, warns the driver or applies the brakes. Depending on the circumstances, it may prevent an impact or reduce its severity.

ADAC believes the problem is probably related primarily to how software recognises and classifies road users. The club considers that updates could resolve the issue in many cases. This is an expert assessment, not confirmation that the cause has been established for every car or that updates are already available.

The test cannot identify from one visible feature which particular strip or item of clothing caused a given system to fail. Manufacturers may use different combinations of sensors and data-processing algorithms.

Do these results change the value of reflective clothing?

No. ADAC continues to recommend conspicuous clothing, especially for children. Its main purpose is to help the driver see a pedestrian earlier. The club considers the benefit of improved visibility greater than the risk associated with a late automatic braking response.

In its advice on children's visibility, ADAC recommends shoes and jackets with reflective elements and checking the reflectors on school backpacks. Drivers benefit from clean windows and headlights, working windscreen wipers and a speed suited to visibility.

What drivers should check in their own car

Having AEB on the equipment list does not mean every car offers the same capabilities. When choosing a car or getting to know one you already own, check:

  • Whether the fitted system detects pedestrians and the conditions in which it operates, as described in the owner's manual.

  • How the car indicates system limitations and where its cameras and other sensors are located.

  • Whether dirt, snow or accessories obstruct the cameras or sensors; consult the manufacturer's instructions for cleaning.

  • Whether updates are available for the specific car and how they are installed, for example through the manufacturer's service network.

When approaching a crossing or parked cars, drivers must be ready to brake themselves. The assistant does not replace attention to the road and may not stop the car in time.

What other tests show

On 14 April 2026, ADAC published a separate test of automatic braking in heavy rain and fog. It involved a different group of six cars and scenarios that differed from the October clothing study. The club found limitations, particularly in dense fog.

Both tests show why car buyers should consider the conditions under which an assistance system was tested as well as whether it is fitted. The reflective-clothing test adds one specific nighttime scenario; by itself, it is not a comprehensive assessment of a car's safety.

Ready to take the next step?

Explore hundreds of listings from verified dealers and private sellers. Smart filters, detailed car pages, and real-time updates — everything you need to make the right choice.

View all cars

Other articles

Toyota Sienna 2027: What Changed and Should You Wait?Choosing and Buying a Car

Toyota Sienna 2027 Promises Better City Fuel Economy: Should You Wait?

November 21, 2026
New Hyundai Elantra 2027 and Elantra Hybrid 2028Korean Automotive Industry

New Hyundai Elantra: What Changed and When to Expect the Hybrid

November 20, 2026
2027 Subaru Forester Wilderness: Hybrid or Gas?Choosing and Buying a Car

2027 Subaru Forester Wilderness Hybrid: What the Extra $1,000 Gets You

November 19, 2026
Mercedes-Benz C 111-II to Be Auctioned for the First TimeGerman cars

Mercedes-Benz C 111 to Be Auctioned for the First Time: What Prototype No. 33 Tested

November 18, 2026
Mercedes-Benz Hands-Free Driving: New Assistant FeaturesGerman cars

Mercedes-Benz Hands-Free Driving: What Its New Highway and City Assistants Can Do

November 17, 2026
Sanrivatti One: Hypercar With a Motorcycle-Style PositionNews

Sanrivatti One: Why This Hypercar Uses a Motorcycle-Style Riding Position

November 16, 2026
2027 Electric Defender: What JLR Has ConfirmedNews

New Electric Defender: Launch Planned for 2027, Name Still Undisclosed

November 15, 2026
New Dacia Spring: Range, Charging and EquipmentNews

New Dacia Spring: More Convenience, but Fast Charging Needs Attention

November 14, 2026
ZF High Revolution Drive: Why Does It Need 30,000 rpm?News

30,000 rpm for Lower Weight: How ZF’s New Electric Drive Works

November 13, 2026
BMW i3 crosses almost 5,900 km with under three hours of chargingGerman cars

Almost 5,900 km with less than three hours of charging: how the BMW i3 crossed Europe

November 12, 2026

Every car listing, in one place.

[email protected]
Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store
Platform
  • Cars
  • About us
  • Blog
  • Contacts
Legal
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Info for dealers
Live now
  • 280.651 Active cars
  • 7.055 Added today
  • 25.535 Sold in 24 h
  • 6.502 Visits per month
  • 156 Visits in 24 h
© 2026 zvelta
EN
EN